Call · 30 min
MarketingMattia Esposito11 November 202614 min read

Levels of awareness and market sophistication. Schwartz's two questions to ask before the first line, in a single table.

Almost every guide lists the five levels of awareness and stops there, leaving out the other half of the question. Here are Schwartz's two scales together, with the table to download.

In brief

In Breakthrough Advertising (1966), Eugene Schwartz asks two questions before an ad is written: how much the customer knows about their problem and your product, and how many similar promises the market has already heard. The first is awareness, the second sophistication.

The book cannot be read legally online, so this page rebuilds it from the public summaries of Josh Kaufman, Taylor Pearson and Joanna Wiebe. A full Italian translation exists, published by Scripta in 2021.

Unaware, Problem aware and the rest are today’s labels. In the book, according to the summaries, the scale starts from the most aware customer.

The level and stage table can be downloaded below, in Word and PDF, with no email required.

Written by: Mattia Esposito, AI and marketing consultant, founder of Itria AI. From Puglia, based in Turin since 2023, he works remotely in Italy and abroad. LinkedIn profile.

The levels of awareness and market sophistication table, to download

A document with the five levels, the five stages and a grid for placing your customer channel by channel, in Word to fill in and in PDF to print. The last column asks for one sentence: my customer is here today because… Write it in their words, not yours.

The level and stage table: the five levels of awareness, the five stages of sophistication and the grid by channel
FileContentsLink
Wordto fill in, in Italian

The five levels and five stages with what to open with, the channel grid to fill in, the sources.

livelli-di-consapevolezza-schwartz-tabella.docx

PDFto print, in Italian

The same table, to keep beside you when you write an ad or a page.

livelli-di-consapevolezza-schwartz-tabella.pdf

Schwartz’s two scales: on the left the customer’s five levels of awareness, on the right the market’s five stages of sophistication; the first line of the ad is chosen where they meet Awareness: what the customer knows Sophistication: what the market has heard Most aware, wants the product Product aware, knows it, has doubts Solution aware, knows what they want Problem aware, feels the problem Unaware, doesn’t know yet Stage 1, the simple promise Stage 2, the bigger promise Stage 3, the new mechanism Stage 4, the improved mechanism Stage 5, identification The first line is chosen where they meet lower down, the opening starts further from the product at later stages, the promise alone persuades less
Breakthrough Advertising’s two scales as the public summaries describe them. On the left, today’s labels in the book’s order, starting from the most aware. On the right, the stages as Taylor Pearson summarises them.

In August, while I was preparing Itria’s first Meta campaign, I read about a hundred ads about artificial intelligence. They all made the same move: first they tell you you’re behind, then they sell you the course to catch up. On 27 August I wrote about one of them: “It makes you anxious and offers you the cure in the same breath.” The full post (in Italian).

In Schwartz’s terms, it’s a market well along in sophistication. Anyone scrolling has already heard the same promise in a hundred versions, and a bigger version only wears them out. In the post I did the opposite: I said what I sell, the result, rather than a second trade to learn.

In October, for a positioning project, I read 1,153 comments under Italian fitness videos. The word “discipline” came up three times. On 13 October the rapper Wiz posted “Discipline is the new luxury” on X, and the post got 202 times his median number of shares. The line names no product and talks about the person who trains: it resembles the fifth stage in the summaries, identification. The post with the data (in Italian).

What I measured myself

A hundred ads, one promise. In August 2026, while preparing Itria’s first Meta campaign, I read about a hundred ads about AI: almost all of them opened with the fear of being left behind.

Three times in 1,153. In comments under Italian fitness videos, in October 2026, the word “discipline” came up three times.

Five words, 202 times. Wiz’s post on X got 44 times the likes, 79 times the saves and 202 times the shares of the median of his last hundred posts.

Eugene Schwartz’s Breakthrough Advertising: the book and its editions

Breakthrough Advertising came out in 1966 from Prentice-Hall, was reissued in English in 1984, 2004 and 2017, and was translated into Italian in 2021. The subtitle is How to Write Ads That Shatter Traditions and Sales Records. Schwartz died in 1995; on Google Books the 2017 reissue also carries the names of Martin Edelston and Brian Kurtz.

YearPublisherPagesCode
1966

Prentice-Hall, first edition

236

LCCN 66012711

1984

Boardroom Books

236

ISBN 0932648541

2004

Bottom Line Books

236

ISBN 9780887232985

2017

Titans Marketing, reissue

262

ISBN 9780998503509

2021

Scripta, Lugano, Italian translation

232

ISBN 9791280128751

Searching for the book in Italian brings up other titles too. Appunti da Breakthrough Advertising, by Andrea Lisi (2015), is a digest, as are the books “in pills”. The full translation is Scripta’s, sold in bookshops, for example on its IBS page.

No copy can be read legitimately online: previews of the recent editions are closed, and the full PDFs in circulation are unauthorised uploads. For this reason the page does not quote the book. It reports what the book says through three public, signed summaries, each named.

What are Eugene Schwartz’s 5 levels of awareness?

A customer may know the product and want it, know it and have doubts, know what they want but not the product, feel a problem with no solution in sight, or not know they have the problem at all. They are five degrees of what the reader knows before reading you, and each calls for a different opening.

Every summary draws the same rule from them. The more the customer knows, the closer to the product you can start. Someone ready to buy needs only the name and the price. Someone who doesn’t know they have a problem turns the page when shown a price. The table uses today’s labels and the book’s order.

LevelWho they areWhat to open withWhere you meet them
1. Most aware

Knows the product and wants it. Waiting for the right moment.

Product name, offer, price, terms. No explanations.

Searches with the brand name and “price”, emails to customers, abandoned baskets.

2. Product aware

Knows the product, not yet convinced.

Proof: data, comparisons, reviews, a guarantee. Why this one and not another.

Searches with the brand and “reviews”, comparisons between two names.

3. Solution aware

Knows what they want to achieve, doesn’t know your product exists.

The result they want, stated boldly; then proof it can be achieved; then the product as the way there.

Searches for “how to…” and “best…”, ads to people who searched the category.

4. Problem aware

Feels a problem, doesn’t link it to a solution.

The problem in their own words, and time spent making it felt, before the solution.

Searches about the symptom, groups and forums, comments under videos in the sector.

5. Unaware

Doesn’t know they have the problem, or won’t admit it.

A story, a fact or a person they recognise themselves in. The product comes late.

Social media to a cold audience, where nobody is looking for anything.

Josh Kaufman, in The Personal MBA, adds a practical use: each marketing contact aims to move the prospect up to the next level. His example is the buyer who has already decided, who should be served straight away, because dwelling on the problem annoys them. He calls the first level Unaware and defines it in one line: “the prospect is not aware of any need or Desire for what you have to offer.”

The “where you meet them” column comes from Joanna Wiebe, who in 2016, on CXL, linked the stages to searches. People who don’t yet know they have a problem type long, general phrases; people who know the product search for the brand; people ready to buy use buying words. Hence a different page for each stage.

Levels of awareness in marketing: today’s labels and the book’s order

The names in circulation, Unaware, Problem aware, Solution aware, Product aware and Most aware, are a simplification that came after the book. Karen Dietz, in Business Storytelling For Dummies (Wiley, 2013), writes that Schwartz’s five levels are sometimes called something else today. Wiebe lists them this way in 2016.

According to Taylor Pearson’s reading notes, Schwartz describes the levels in sentences and orders them the opposite way round to today’s guides: from most aware to least aware. Perry Marshall, Keith Krance and Thomas Meloche use the same order in their Ultimate Guide to Facebook Advertising (2017), which starts from Most aware.

N.The level, in Pearson’s summaryCurrent label (Wiebe, 2016)Kaufman’s label
1

The most aware customer: knows the product and wants it

Most aware

Full awareness

2

Knows the product but doesn’t want it yet

Product or brand aware

Offer awareness

3

Knows what they want, not that a product does it

Solution aware

Solution awareness

4

Has a need and doesn’t link it to the product

Problem aware

Problem awareness

5

The completely unaware market

Completely unaware

Unaware

The order matters to a writer. Read from the top, the scale tells you how much work is needed before you can name the product, and the work grows as you go down. Guides that start from Unaware describe the customer’s journey instead, which is why so many draw a funnel: Kaufman uses the same image.

The 5 stages of market sophistication

Sophistication measures how many similar promises your market has already heard, and it changes what you can still promise. In Pearson’s summary there are five stages: the simple promise, the bigger promise, the mechanism, the improved mechanism, and identification with the buyer. Other summaries give the same stages different names.

The turning point is stage three. Pearson sums it up like this: “Your prospects have heard the claims and all the dramatizations have been taken to the very edge of believability.” From there the ad stops saying what the product does and explains how it does it. The example below follows a made-up company, Forno Aurora, through the five stages.

StageWhat the market has already heardWhat you writeForno Aurora (made-up company)
Stage 1

Nothing like it: you are first.

The promise, simple and direct, in the headline.

Forno Aurora, the first bakery in town to deliver bread: “Warm bread at your door, at 7.”

Stage 2

Your promise, repeated by a competitor.

The same promise, bigger or with a guarantee.

“Warm bread at your door in 20 minutes, or it’s free.”

Stage 3

Ever bigger promises, now at the edge of belief.

How it works: the mechanism that makes the promise true.

“The oven rides in the van: your bread bakes on the way.”

Stage 4

The mechanism, copied by others.

The mechanism extended or improved.

“The only wood-fired oven on wheels: the crust stays crisp.”

Stage 5

Everything. The market no longer believes ads.

The buyer: identity, taste, the group they belong to.

“For people who won’t eat yesterday’s bread at breakfast.”

Derek Halpern, on Social Triggers, runs the same exercise with water and with weight loss. For stage two he cites Domino’s 30-minute delivery guarantee: the promise is still pizza at your door, and the guarantee makes it bigger. A guarantee like that has to be honoured, and this is the first point where the copy meets the rules.

Stage five, in Pearson’s summary, is for a market that no longer believes advertising. Attention moves from the promise and the mechanism to the buyer. This is brand territory: what choosing the product says about you. How to build that positioning is covered in the guide on how to create a brand.

Awareness and sophistication: the difference, and how to use them together

Awareness is about the customer and sophistication is about the market: the first tells you where your first line starts, the second which promise you can put in it. The two scales are often mixed up, even in the questions Google suggests, because both are about what the reader already knows.

Use them in sequence. First place the customer: someone searching “too much waste in production” is describing a symptom and is Problem aware, while someone searching your name with “price” is Most aware. Then look at the market: if every competitor promises the same thing, your bare promise won’t do and you need a mechanism.

The same customer can sit at different levels on different channels, which is why the file has a grid by channel. A person who finds you by searching for your brand and a person who meets you in a sponsored post are in different places at that moment. Copy for the first is short; for the second it starts from the problem.

How to tell which level of awareness your customer is at

Look at what they write when nobody is selling them anything: their searches, their questions in groups, their comments under videos in your sector. If they use the name of your product, they are high on the scale; if they describe a nuisance without naming any solution, they are at level four; if they don’t mention it at all, at level five.

Words can be counted. In the comments I read in October, “discipline” came up three times in 1,153, yet Wiz’s line with that word got 202 times his usual shares. The count tells you which language the reader uses; the line that moves them sometimes puts a name to something they hadn’t named yet. Where to find those words is in the guide on understanding customers before you write.

To join the conversation the customer is already having, the sister page covers the conversation in the customer’s mind, with Robert Collier. The sentence for the last column of the grid comes from there: my customer is here today because, written as they would say it.

Levels of awareness in Facebook and Instagram ads

On social media a cold audience isn’t looking for anything, so an ad that reaches it is almost always speaking to a customer at levels four and five. Campaigns aimed at people who have already visited your site speak to someone who knows the product, and can open with the offer.

Marshall, Krance and Meloche apply Schwartz’s scale to Facebook advertising in their 2017 book, rewriting it as a sequence of their own. In practice: one campaign, several pieces of copy, one per level. How to write the copy for an ad, field by field, is in the guide on how to write a Meta ad.

To see which stage your market is at, the quickest source is the Meta Ad Library: your competitors’ live ads side by side. If they all repeat the same promise, you are at stage two or beyond. Openings can be taken apart with the grid in the hook and headline examples.

Most aware, prices and deadlines: where copy meets the rules

At the first level the opening is the offer, with price and terms, and there the copy falls under the rules on commercial practices. In Italy these are articles 20 to 27 of the Consumer Code, which transpose EU Directive 2005/29; in the UK, section 3 of the CAP Code; in the United States, the FTC’s rules.

Deadlines are the delicate point. Among the practices treated as misleading in all circumstances, article 23 of the Italian Consumer Code lists false urgency: saying an offer lasts a very short time when it doesn’t. The same ban appears in Annex I of Directive 2005/29.

The stage-two guarantee and the stage-three mechanism are claims that can be checked as well. The full table for Italy, the EU, the UK and the US, with the authorities, is on the page about hooks and headlines; in the UK the reference is the CAP Code, section 3.

The two scales sit at the centre of the copywriting section of the index of marketing guides for SMEs. The starting point is the main guide to copywriting for SMEs; copy written to measure is the work described in copy and sales materials.

Questions and answers

What are Eugene Schwartz's 5 levels of awareness?

In the summaries of the book there are five: people who know the product and want it, people who know it but are not convinced, people who know what they want but not that the product exists, people who feel a need without linking it to a solution, and people who don’t know they have one. Marketers today call them Most aware, Product aware, Solution aware, Problem aware and Unaware.

What is the difference between awareness and market sophistication?

Awareness is about the customer: how much they know about their problem and your product. Sophistication is about the market: how many similar promises it has already heard. The first decides where your opening starts, the second which kind of promise can still persuade.

Is Breakthrough Advertising available in Italian?

Yes. The full translation was published by Scripta, in Lugano, in 2021 (ISBN 9791280128751). Earlier Italian books with Breakthrough Advertising in the title, such as Andrea Lisi’s notes from 2015, are digests rather than translations.

Are the names Unaware, Problem Aware and Solution Aware Schwartz's own?

They are later labels. They appear in this form in Joanna Wiebe’s 2016 guide, and Josh Kaufman uses different ones again. According to the summaries of the book, Schwartz describes each level in a sentence and starts from the most aware customer.

How can I tell which stage of sophistication my market is at?

Look at your competitors’ live ads in the Meta Ad Library and at the first lines of their websites. If they repeat the same promise, you are at stage two at least; if the promise comes with a mechanism, at stage three or four; if the ads talk about the buyer more than the product, at stage five.

Notes on sources

  1. Eugene M. Schwartz, Breakthrough Advertising, Prentice-Hall, 1966; editions and codes from Open Library and the Google Books records by ISBN. Italian edition: Scripta, Lugano, 2021, IBS page. The book is not quoted: no legitimate copy can be read online. Read on 11 November 2026.
  2. Josh Kaufman, Levels of Awareness, entry in The Personal MBA (from the book, Portfolio, 2010): the names of the five levels and the quoted line. An author’s summary, with his own labels. Read on 11 November 2026.
  3. Taylor Pearson, reading notes on Breakthrough Advertising, 23 June 2020, updated 6 June 2025: the order of the levels of awareness and the five stages of sophistication, and the quoted line. Personal notes. Read on 11 November 2026.
  4. Joanna Wiebe, How to Write Copy That Sells, CXL, 21 January 2016, updated 16 September 2020: the current labels and the link with searches.
  5. Derek Halpern, Social Triggers: examples of the stages, including the Domino’s guarantee. A marketing blog, used for examples only. Read on 11 November 2026.
  6. Karen Dietz, Business Storytelling For Dummies, Wiley, 2013; Perry Marshall, Keith Krance and Thomas Meloche, Ultimate Guide to Facebook Advertising, Entrepreneur Press, 2017. Consulted through Internet Archive full-text search excerpts.
  7. Italian Consumer Code, article 23 on Normattiva; Directive 2005/29/EC, text on EUR-Lex, Annex I; ASA and CAP, CAP Code, section 3.
  8. The counts of ads, comments and Wiz’s post come from Mattia Esposito’s public LinkedIn posts of 27 August and 21 October 2026.
·Who does it for you

The table tells you where your customer stands. Finding out what your competitors have already told them is market analysis. Positioning is built starting from the market.

Mattia Esposito, who wrote this guide, also works with Itria on positioning: in-depth market analysis to find where competitors are exposed and take that ground. He did it on his own site first. In August, asked who had founded itria.io, ChatGPT couldn’t find him. From 11 October to 7 November 2026 itria.io pages appeared 13,803 times in Google and Bing results and 3,818 times in AI answers: Google’s AI Overviews and AI Mode, and Microsoft Copilot.