AI Overviews and falling traffic. How to work out, query by query, whether Google’s summary took the clicks you lost.
When clicks fall, the AI Overview gets the blame straight away. Sometimes rightly, sometimes the page has lost positions or demand has dropped. Here is the Excel sheet to tell the cases apart.
With an AI summary on the page people click less: according to Pew Research Center, 8% of visits end on a traditional result, against 15% without a summary. The data is from March 2025, in the United States, and it remains the only independent measurement published.
Google maintains that total organic clicks are relatively stable, but publishes no figures. In the Search Console help it only documents how clicks, impressions and position are counted for AI Overviews, with no separate filter.
A drop is attributed query by query: if position and impressions hold and clicks fall, the drop is consistent with an AI Overview, and the proof is searching the query by hand.
The sheet is free to download below, in Excel, with the procedure as a PDF, no email required.
Written by: Mattia Esposito, AI and marketing consultant, founder of Itria AI. From Puglia, based in Turin since 2023, he works remotely in Italy and abroad. LinkedIn profile.
The “Is the drop down to AI Overviews?” sheet, free to download
An Excel sheet where you paste your Search Console export, last three months against the same three months a year earlier, and which works out the changes for each query and suggests a clue. You give the verdict after searching the query by hand. You need access to Search Console; thirty queries take about an hour.

| File | Contents | Link |
|---|---|---|
| Excelto fill in, in Italian | The Query, Thresholds, How to fill it in and Sources sheets, with changes, clue and totals that calculate themselves. | |
| PDFto read, in Italian | The seven-step procedure, the clue line by line and the click data with its sources. |
| Column | What goes in | Where from |
|---|---|---|
| Query and page | The search and the page that receives it. | Search Console, Performance |
| Impressions, clicks, position | Before and after, with the change calculated, and the CTR for both periods. | Export with Compare |
| Words in the query | Counted by the sheet: longer searches get a summary more often. | Calculated |
| Clue | Lost position, fewer searches, or consistent with an AI Overview. | Calculated, thresholds editable |
| Page in the AI report | Whether the page has impressions in generative AI features. | Generative AI report |
| AI Overview by hand | Whether a summary appears when you search the query, and what it cites. | Google, private window |
| Verdict | Consistent with an AI Overview, lost position, seasonality or other. | You, after the check |
In September, on my own site, the three pages I had worked hardest on sat in positions 5, 6 and 9 and got zero clicks. On 13 September I opened those three searches by hand: all three had an AI Overview at the top, and itria.io was cited in none of them. Inside were the body that issues the rule and, in one case, a courier.
The same month a single page brought in 12 of the site’s 34 clicks. It was a Word template for a product specification sheet, in position 12, clicked by 23% of the people who saw it. I put it like this: “A Word file can’t be summarised.” The rest of the reasoning is in the post of 21 September.
The sheet is that check put in order. It does not find the AI Overview innocent or guilty: it separates the queries where the drop has another explanation from the ones worth searching by hand.
Do AI Overviews take traffic? What the impact studies say
The most robust independent measurement comes from Pew Research Center: 900 US adults who shared their browsing, 68,879 Google searches in March 2025. Pew puts it this way: “Users who encountered an AI summary clicked on a traditional search result link in 8% of all visits.” Without a summary, 15%.
The same study gives other useful figures. A link inside the summary was clicked in 1% of visits. After a page with a summary 26% ended their browsing, against 16% without. A summary appeared in 18% of searches, but in 8% of one- or two-word searches and in 53% of searches of ten words or more.
| Data | Source | Kind of source |
|---|---|---|
| Clicks on a traditional result: 8% with an AI summary, 15% without | Pew Research Center, 22 July 2025 (United States, March 2025) | Independent |
| Clicks on a link inside the summary: 1% of visits | Pew Research Center, 22 July 2025 | Independent |
| Searches with a summary: 8% of 1-2 word searches, 53% of 10 words or more | Pew Research Center, 22 July 2025 | Independent |
| 60% of US adults say they read AI summaries | Pew Research Center, survey, 17 June 2026 | Independent, survey |
| First-position CTR about 34.5% lower with an AI Overview | Ahrefs, 300,000 keywords, estimate | SEO tool vendor |
| Total organic clicks “relatively stable” year on year | Google, blog, 6 August 2025, no data | Partisan |
In 2026 Pew ran a survey, not a new measurement: 60% of US adults say they read the AI summaries at the top of results. Ahrefs, an SEO tool vendor, estimated across 300,000 informational keywords a first-position CTR 34.5% lower when an AI Overview is present. All these figures are American: no independent measurement of clicks has been published for Italy.
There is a limit to bear in mind. Pew measures how often people click on a results page, Ahrefs estimates an average CTR: neither measures your site’s traffic. A national percentage cannot tell you which of your queries lost clicks, which is why the check is run on your own data.
What Google says, and what it does not publish
On 6 August 2025 Liz Reid, head of Search, wrote that “total organic click volume from Google Search to websites has been relatively stable year-over-year”. In the same article Google says quality clicks, the ones after which the user does not bounce straight back, have risen slightly, and calls third-party reports inaccurate.
The article also describes a shift: traffic falls for some sites and rises for others, with forums, video and first-person voices on the up. For quick-answer questions, such as the date of the next full moon, Google acknowledges people may not click at all. It publishes neither the figures nor the method: this is one side’s position, like the publishers’.
How to check AI Overview traffic in Search Console
In the Search Console help Google writes that an AI Overview occupies a single position in the results: “all links in the AI Overview are assigned that same position”. A click on an external link in the summary counts as a click, and the impression follows the normal rules. In AI Mode a follow-up question counts as a new search.
Search Central adds that AI Overviews and AI Mode are counted in the Performance report, under the Web search type, together with classic results. There is no “AI Overview” filter. The consequence, a deduction and not a sentence of Google’s, is that a page cited in the summary can earn an impression in a high position without a click, and its average CTR drops.
Hence the rule found in many guides: stable impressions and falling clicks mean AI Overview. Google writes it nowhere. The rule makes a reasonable hypothesis to be checked, because the same numbers also appear when a competitor takes first place with a better snippet, or when the page loses its position on one query and keeps it on another.
So the sheet looks at position first, then impressions, and only at the end at clicks. How to export the year-on-year comparison is explained step by step in the Search Console guide.
The AI features report: what it shows and what it does not
Since 31 August 2026 Search Console has offered every site a performance report for generative AI features, with impressions by page, country, date and device. The report’s help page describes impressions and mentions neither clicks nor queries. It tells you which pages appear in summaries; to measure a drop in clicks you still need the Performance report.
In the sheet the report fills a single column: does the page that lost clicks have impressions in AI features, yes or no. How to read it in full is in the guide on how to appear in AI Overviews; how to build it into a monthly measure with Bing and GA4, in the one on how to measure GEO.
How to track AI Overview traffic in GA4: why you cannot see it separately
Since 13 May 2026 Google Analytics 4 has had an AI Assistant channel for visits from assistants such as ChatGPT, Gemini and Copilot, and the help page is plain about it: “It excludes Google’s AI Overviews and AI Mode”. Visits arriving from a Google summary stay in organic search, along with all the rest.
In GA4, then, AI Overview traffic cannot be isolated. You can compare the organic traffic of the pages the sheet marks as consistent with an AI Overview against the others, but it remains an indirect comparison. The figure closest to the source is in Search Console.
AI Overviews and traffic in Italy: publishers, AGCOM and the European Commission
In Italy the issue reached the regulators through the publishers. On 15 October 2025 FIEG, the federation of newspaper publishers, filed a complaint with AGCOM; in its technical note, the federation says, it explains how Google is becoming a “traffic killer”. This is one side’s position, like Google’s.
On 30 April 2026 AGCOM, as Italy’s Digital Services Coordinator, “ha deciso di trasmettere alla Commissione europea una richiesta di valutazione”, decided to send the European Commission a request to assess AI Overviews and AI Mode under Articles 27, 34 and 35 of the Digital Services Act, with one commissioner voting against. So AGCOM did not open proceedings of its own: it sent a referral to the Commission.
| Where | What happened | Date |
|---|---|---|
| Italy, FIEG | Complaint to AGCOM against AI Overviews. Partisan. | 15 October 2025 |
| Italy, AGCOM | Request to the Commission to assess AI Overviews and AI Mode under the Digital Services Act. | 30 April 2026 |
| European Union | Commission antitrust investigation into the use of publishers’ content for AI Overviews and AI Mode. No outcome. | 9 December 2025 |
| United Kingdom | The CMA requires Google to give publishers tools to keep their content out of AI features in Search. | 3 June 2026 |
| United States | No regulatory requirement among the sources read; Pew’s click data comes from here. | As of 10 November 2026 |
At European level the Commission opened an investigation into possible abuse of a dominant position on 9 December 2025: it suspects Google of using publishers’ content for its summaries “without appropriate compensation to publishers and without offering them the possibility to refuse such use of their content”. Opening an investigation does not prejudge the outcome. The United Kingdom is the only country where a regulator, the CMA, has already imposed a requirement, on 3 June 2026.
What a small business can do when the drop is down to AI Overviews
If the check says the drop is consistent with an AI Overview, there are two routes: get cited inside the summary, or offer something the summary cannot give. For the first, Google’s rules on AI features apply, gathered in the AI Overviews guide; the short definition is in the glossary under AI Overview.
For the second, the type of question matters. On a quick answer the click does not come back, and your effort is better spent elsewhere. On a question about getting something done, a template to fill in, a calculation or a comparison stays on the site: the case of the Word specification sheet described above.
There is also the way out: Google offers levers to remove pages from the summaries, at the cost of losing the visibility they bring. The three levers, with their effects, are in the guide on how to turn off AI Overviews. Before pulling them, find out how many of your queries really have a summary, which is the count the sheet makes.
The pages that never existed. Without a real 404 page, five addresses that had never existed were earning impressions in first position: a case of impressions without clicks that had nothing to do with AI, in the ghost URLs.
From one page to five. On the morning of 25 September 2026, for Claude’s web search, itria.io had a single page; by the evening, after asking Brave to recrawl seven, it had five. In Brave and Claude.
The result. Between 11 October and 7 November 2026 Search Console counted 3,550 impressions of itria.io pages in AI Overviews and AI Mode, and Bing’s AI Performance report 268 citations in Copilot.
The work on a real company, with the questions to cover and who is cited in your place today, is described on the page about presence in search engines and AI assistants. The other guides are in the index of marketing for small businesses.
Questions and answers
Do AI Overviews take traffic away from websites?
The most cited independent study says clicks fall: according to Pew Research Center, with an AI summary on the page users clicked a traditional result in 8% of visits, against 15% without. The data is from March 2025, in the United States.
Google maintains that total organic clicks are relatively stable, but has published neither figures nor method.
How can I tell whether my site's drop is caused by AI Overviews?
In Search Console, compare the last three months with the same three months a year earlier, query by query. If position and impressions hold and clicks fall, the drop is consistent with an AI Overview. Then search the query by hand: that check decides, because Google publishes no rule for attributing a drop to its summaries.
Does Search Console have a filter for AI Overview traffic?
No. Google says AI Overviews and AI Mode are counted in the Performance report, under the Web search type, together with classic Search. The generative AI performance report, available to every site since 31 August 2026, shows impressions by page: its help page describes neither clicks nor queries.
Does GA4 show visits from AI Overviews?
Not separately. The AI Assistant channel in GA4, introduced in May 2026, counts visits from assistants such as ChatGPT and Copilot and explicitly excludes Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode, which stay in organic search.
Has anyone in Italy filed a complaint against AI Overviews?
FIEG, the Italian federation of newspaper publishers, filed a complaint with AGCOM, the communications regulator, on 15 October 2025. On 30 April 2026 AGCOM sent the European Commission a request to assess AI Overviews and AI Mode under the Digital Services Act. Separately, since 9 December 2025 the Commission has had an antitrust investigation open into Google. Neither has reached an outcome yet.
Notes on sources
- Pew Research Center, Athena Chapekis and Anna Lieb, Google users are less likely to click on links when an AI summary appears in the results, 22 July 2025: 900 US adults, 68,879 searches from March 2025; source of the quoted sentence. Read on 10 November 2026.
- Pew Research Center, Americans and AI 2026, 17 June 2026: survey from February 2026.
- Google, Liz Reid, AI in Search is driving more queries and higher quality clicks, 6 August 2025. Partisan source, no data published.
- Search Console Help, Performance report data and Generative AI performance report; Google Search Central, AI features and your website, updated on 10 December 2025, CC BY 4.0.
- Google Analytics Help, Default channel group, AI Assistant channel (entry of 13 May 2026).
- Ahrefs, AI Overviews Reduce Clicks by 34.5%, 17 April 2025, updated on 5 June 2026: a study by an SEO tool vendor, CTR estimate across 300,000 keywords.
- European Commission, IP/25/2964, 9 December 2025, source of the quoted sentence.
- FIEG, press release of 15 October 2025, partisan source; AGCOM, press release of 30 April 2026 and resolution no. 104/26/CONS.
- Competition and Markets Authority, CMA secures fairer deal for publishers, 3 June 2026, Open Government Licence v3.0.
- The itria.io figures come from Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools; the September clicks from the post of 21 September 2026; the AI window runs from 11 October to 7 November 2026.
Knowing where the drop comes from is the first step. Getting chosen over your competitors is the work that follows. Positioning is built starting from the market.
Mattia Esposito, who wrote this guide, also works with Itria on positioning: in-depth market analysis to find where competitors are exposed and take that ground. He did it on his own site first. In August, asked who had founded itria.io, ChatGPT couldn’t find him. From 11 October to 7 November 2026 itria.io pages appeared 13,803 times in Google and Bing results and 3,818 times in AI answers: Google’s AI Overviews and AI Mode, and Microsoft Copilot.