Call · 30 min
Behind the curtainMattia Esposito12 November 202612 min read

Instagram theme pages. What they are, how they grow, and what I learnt from counting the 632,288 likes on mine, one by one.

A theme page grows on what the curator puts next to the images, and on my own archive hashtags and tagged locations changed nothing. Here are the numbers, counted, Instagram’s 2026 rules and the sheet to measure your own posts.

In brief

A theme page is a page devoted to a single theme, posting selected content, often other people’s, usually with no face behind it. Mine, @artartism, posted paintings: at 16, 632,288 organic likes in 7 months, counted one by one, 55,000 followers and 10 million views in a month.

Since 30 April 2026 the rules have changed. Instagram writes that accounts mostly posting unoriginal content, now including photos and carousels, are no longer shown in recommendations; a different caption is not enough to make the content original.

On my archive, one line next to the painting earned 2.3 times the month’s median; hashtags, credits and tagged locations, nothing. One account and one period: it is a method to repeat on your own data.

The Excel sheet to do it is free to download below, with a filled-in example as a PDF, no email required.

Written by: Mattia Esposito, AI and marketing consultant, founder of Itria AI. From Puglia, based in Turin since 2023, he works remotely in Italy and abroad. LinkedIn profile.

The sheet to measure your posts, to download

An Excel sheet with one post per row, which compares each post with the median of the same month’s posts without a line and summarises by type of line. I used this method on the @artartism archive, because a growing page gets more likes in March than in September even if nothing changes. Comparing within the same month removes that effect.

Filled-in example of the sheet for measuring an Instagram theme page’s posts, with the monthly median and each post’s ratio
FileContentsLink
Excelto fill in, in Italian

The sheet with 60 rows, the calculated columns and the summary by type of line; a second sheet with the example.

theme-page-instagram-misura-post.xlsx

PDFexample

The example filled in for a made-up page, to show how to read it.

theme-page-instagram-misura-post-esempio.pdf

ColumnWhy it’s thereWhere it comes from
Date and format

Feed ranking takes into account when and how a post was published.

Instagram, 2023

Line alongside

The variable that explained most on my archive: none, quote, story, my own reading, explanation.

The @artartism archive

Question

On its own it did little; together with the line, a lot.

The @artartism archive

Originality

Instagram looks at the share of original posts over a rolling 30 days.

Instagram, 30 April 2026

Rights to the work

Anyone posting declares that they hold the rights to what they share.

Instagram Terms of Use

Hashtags

To check on your own data what made no difference on my archive.

The @artartism archive

Likes, comments, saves, shares

They are among the signals Instagram declares for the Feed.

Instagram, 2023

Monthly median and ratio

The month’s 1x, calculated on the posts without a line, and how far each post sits above or below it.

The method

I started @artartism as a teenager: the first post I could find is from 2 November 2020. I posted paintings, and the audience was mostly international and over fifty. When a post took off, plenty of teenagers reposted it, sometimes my own friends, who had no idea it was mine. I was embarrassed by it and never told anyone.

This year I took the posts and their numbers and counted them. At 16, over 7 months and 255 posts, the page collected 632,288 organic likes, with no advertising. I compared every post with the others from the same month and drew some principles from it, which I set out in my post of 25 September. I put the first one like this: “One line alongside doubles the image.”

Instagram theme page: what it is

A theme page is an account devoted to a single theme, posting content selected around it, often taken from others, and usually without showing who runs it. It is also called a faceless page. The theme can be anything: paintings, architecture, vintage cars, quotes, recipes.

What it offers is the selection, the rhythm and what the curator puts alongside, more than the content itself, which often already exists elsewhere. For years the model was to repost a lot, every day, with apps that made reposting effortless. Instagram decided in 2026 to stop pushing exactly that model.

Theme pages and originality: what changes from 30 April 2026

On 30 April 2026 Instagram extended to photos and carousels the originality rules that had applied to reels since 2024: accounts that mostly repost other people’s work are no longer recommended. The announcement says these accounts “will no longer be shown in places where we recommend content”, in other words Explore and suggestions to people who don’t follow them.

Three details matter for a theme page. Followers keep seeing the posts as before. An account becomes eligible again when a significant percentage of its recent posts is original, over a rolling 30-day window, and you can check the status under Account Status. And borders, watermarks, subtitles or a credit in the caption are not enough.

The originality guidelines say it in one sentence: “Simply adding a different caption or superficial elements to third-party content would not qualify as materially edited content.” So the line that doubled likes on my archive does not make a reposted painting original in Instagram’s eyes. They are two different things: one is how much people who see a post like it, the other is whether Instagram shows it to people who don’t follow you.

What a theme page doesFor Instagram’s recommendations, from 30 April 2026
Reposts a painting as it is

Unoriginal content, even with the artist credited.

Reposts it with a different caption

Not enough to make it original, according to the guidelines.

Adds a border, watermark or subtitles

Not enough, according to the announcement.

Substantially edits the content

Can count as original: Instagram’s test is whether, with your contribution removed, it would be almost the same.

Posts photos, text or carousels you made yourself

Original.

Shares someone else’s post with the repost feature or in Stories

The route Instagram suggests for curating without edits.

How to grow an Instagram page: what I measured

On my archive, what sat next to the painting mattered far more than anything else. The rule is simple: a post with only the painting and the artist counts as 1x, and every other post is compared with those from the same month. The numbers below are counted from the post file; where the cases are few, I say so.

What sat next to the paintingPerformance against the month’s medianPosts
Just the painting and the artist

1x, the baseline. In November 2022 the median was 1,000 likes.

7

A line: a quote, a story, what I saw in it

2.30x. In November 2022 the median was 2,300 likes.

46

An encyclopaedia-style description

1.51x

12

My own emotional reading

2.50x

5

Just a question

1.12x

whole archive

A line and a question

4.43x

10

Living or contemporary artists

2.30x, against 1.42x for historical paintings.

23 e 161

Hashtags, credit, tagged location

No effect: 1.00x with 0-22 hashtags, 0.98x with 30 or more, 0.98x with a credit, 0.89x with a location.

whole archive; with location, 10

How an @artartism post performed against the month’s median, depending on what sat next to the image Just the paintingJust a question Just a lineLine and question 0,98x1,12x 2,17x4,43x 1x = the median of posts with just the painting, in the same month
How a post performed against its month’s median, depending on what sat next to the painting. The @artartism archive, 2022-2023; the line with the question is based on just 10 posts.

Two examples give a sense of it. The same Anne Magill painting, with just the question, got 40 comments; reposted with the question and a Nietzsche quote, 97. And a painting by Annie Stegg, a living artist, got 15,300 likes, around eight times Klimt’s The Kiss posted with a quote from Rostand, which got 1,900.

One comparison, on the other hand, doesn’t hold up, and I say so because I used it myself. Marcus Aurelius on death got 12,000 likes and Woody Allen 903, but there were two different paintings underneath: the number mixes image and text, and you can’t tell which of the two made the difference. This is why the sheet has a column for the work.

How to grow on Instagram from zero, organically

Instagram says it has no single algorithm: Feed, Stories, Explore, Reels and search each have their own system, and for the Feed the main signals are the viewer’s activity, information about the post, who posted it and the history of interactions between the two. Information about the post includes how many likes come in and how fast, comments, shares and saves.

Adam Mosseri’s explanation opens with this sentence: “Instagram doesn’t have a singular algorithm that oversees what people do and don’t see on the app.” The number of hashtags is not among the declared signals, which matches what I saw on my archive. So what you can do from zero is work on what makes viewers react: what sits next to the image, the right question, the rhythm.

A study by Socialinsider, an analytics vendor, across 9.1 million posts from business pages says captions under 30 words perform better. It looks like the opposite of the line, but it measures something else: length, on business pages. On my archive length explained nothing; the layer the line added did. The two figures don’t add up to one rule. How to build a publishing calendar is covered in the guide to the social media content plan.

Reposting paintings on Instagram: copyright

A public-domain painting can be reproduced, but a living artist is protected, and some of the biggest likes on my archive came precisely from works by living artists. Rereading it, that was the part that struck me most: the line doubled the likes, and contemporary works outperformed the classics, in other words the works still under copyright.

WhereHow long rights last, and copies of a painting now out of copyrightSource
Italy

The artist’s whole life plus 70 years; a reproduction of a visual artwork out of copyright is not protected, unless it is an original work. Italy’s rules on cultural heritage held by museums still apply.

Italian Law 633/1941, arts. 25 and 32-quater

European Union

A reproduction of a visual artwork in the public domain is not protected, unless it is original.

Directive 2019/790, art. 14

United Kingdom

70 years after the artist’s death; on digital copies of expired works the UK office admits some uncertainty, but considers it unlikely that a merely retouched copy is original.

gov.uk, IPO

United States

For works created from 1978, the artist’s life plus 70 years; for earlier works the term varies. Fair use is assessed case by case and is not a licence.

U.S. Copyright Office

Instagram, everywhere

The originality rules are separate from copyright: a public-domain painting reposted without changes is still unoriginal for recommendations.

Instagram, 30 April 2026

Italian law puts it this way: material resulting from the reproduction of an expired work is not subject to copyright or related rights, unless it constitutes an original work (faithful paraphrase). And Instagram’s Terms ask anyone posting to declare that they hold all the necessary rights. The question of AI-generated images, which raises similar issues, is covered on the page about copyright and AI images.

Theme pages and money: why I quit

I found no serious source with reliable figures on how much a theme page earns, and I quote none here. Searching “theme page instagram” turns up Reddit threads, Medium posts and videos, and the earnings figures can’t be checked.

I quit before trying. The page was doing well: 55,000 followers, 680 posts, one a day, 10 million views in a month, zero spent on advertising. There was only one reason: fear of monetising. My girlfriend at the time and my parents knew, nobody else. In my post of 8 September I also described how I worked: an hour or so a day looking for posts that had done well, to repost with repost apps that, in my view, broke the terms of use outrageously. “Incredibly handy, I used them anyway.”

On the terms, to be precise: Instagram’s prohibit accessing or collecting information by automated means without permission, and infringing other people’s rights. They don’t name repost apps. That those apps broke the rules remains my own judgement, not a rule.

What I took from it, beyond Instagram

The principle that stays is that audiences react to the layer you add, not the content you repeat. On @artartism it was the line next to the painting; on a company profile it is the real case next to the figure, the sentence nobody else could have written. The guides on how social media multiplies results and on how to write hooks and headlines make the same point.

The other is the method: compare within the same month, count the cases, write the limits next to the number. The sheet in the guide to personal branding on LinkedIn offers the same comparison, and I use it for everything else. The other tests with numbers are in the Behind the curtain section, including 521 hours in the markets with AI agents and what the law says about collecting contacts from social media.

Questions and answers

What is an Instagram theme page?

A page devoted to a single theme, such as paintings, vintage cars or quotes, that posts selected content, often taken from others, usually with no face behind it. Its value is the selection and what the curator adds.

Can a theme page still grow on Instagram in 2026?

Yes, but not by reposting alone. Since 30 April 2026 Instagram has stopped recommending accounts that mostly post unoriginal content, photos and carousels included, and a different caption is not enough to make it original. Followers still see the posts; an account becomes eligible again with a significant share of original posts over 30 days.

Do hashtags help you grow on Instagram?

On the @artartism archive they made no difference: with 0-22 hashtags posts earned 1.00 times the month’s median, with 30 or more 0.98. In Instagram’s own explanation of ranking, hashtags do not appear among the main Feed signals. It is one account over one period: measure it on your own.

Can I repost famous paintings on a theme page?

It depends on the work. In Italy and the EU, rights generally last until 70 years after the artist’s death, and a faithful reproduction of a work now out of copyright creates no new rights; living artists, on the other hand, are protected. For Instagram, a public-domain painting reposted without changes is still unoriginal content. This is not legal advice.

Can you make money from a theme page?

I found no serious source with reliable figures, and I quote none here. I quit before trying, out of fear of monetising. Anyone who tries has two things to weigh: the rights to the works they post and the originality rules, which decide whether the page is shown to people who don’t follow it.

Notes on sources

  1. Instagram for Creators, Rewarding original creators on Instagram, 30 April 2026, and Original content guidelines: the two quotations come from here. Read on 12 November 2026.
  2. Instagram, Instagram Ranking Explained, Adam Mosseri, 31 May 2023; Instagram for Creators, Recommendations on Instagram, 2022, updated in 2023.
  3. Italian Law no. 633 of 22 April 1941, art. 25 (term extended to 70 years by Law 52/1996) and art. 32-quater, in force since 12 December 2021 (in Italian).
  4. Directive (EU) 2019/790, art. 14, text read from the official copy on legislation.gov.uk.
  5. United Kingdom: How long copyright lasts and the IPO notice on digital images. United States: U.S. Copyright Office, copyright duration and fair use.
  6. Socialinsider, Instagram caption length, updated on 19 October 2026: a vendor study, 9,117,401 posts from 82,952 business pages, 2023 data.
  7. The @artartism likes come from the post archive, recounted on 12 November 2026: 632,288 likes across 255 posts in 7 months. Followers, posts and views are those in the post of 8 September 2026. The comparisons are internal to a single account, with no controlled experiments; where there are fewer than 10 posts, the figure is a pointer.
·Behind the curtain

I counted the likes on a page I had left behind. The method still works, on something else entirely.

This page is part of Behind the curtain: the things I have actually tried, with the numbers counted and the limits written alongside. Mattia Esposito, founder of Itria AI.